Like CurlingZone on Facebook
 
 
   
Welcome to CurlingZone, Guest!   Register Now!    
Already a member?   Login:              Forgot Password?
ProCurlingWear - Support Our Troops
Disclaimer: CurlingZone does not represent or endorse the accuracy or reliability of any Content posted on any Forums area and you acknowledge that any reliance upon such Content shall be at your sole risk. Any Content placed on any Forums area by users and anonymous posters are the views of the user posting the statement, and do not represent the views of CurlingZone or our partners, advertisers or sponsors. By posting anonymously, you are allowing your IP address to be displayed for identification purposes. CurlingZone reserves the right to remove any post at its discretion without warning or explanation.
Pages (3): « 1 2 [3]   Last Thread   Next Thread
Author
Thread Post New Thread    Post A Reply
SkipsWhoSayNi
Harvey Hacksmasher

Registered: May 2015
Location:
Posts: 30

I was incredulous in finding that almost all Olympic sports that are based on a game have a system to dissuade the top talent from participating and to protect their own chosen national teams.

I tried to get a basketball team together to challenge for an Olympic berth but was told no.

I think they are taking a page from the HPP. It's Un-American .

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-03-17 02:55PM
SkipsWhoSayNi is offline Click Here to See the Profile for SkipsWhoSayNi Find more posts by SkipsWhoSayNi Add SkipsWhoSayNi to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AlanMacNeill
Drawmaster

Registered: Sep 2011
Location:
Posts: 919

Those other team sports also allow for substitution in the middle of a game, at the coach's discretion for strategic purposes, of multiple players off of a deep bench. As such, it is possible, even probable, that the 2nd best team's starters are better players than the bench players of the best team, and as such, would result in a better team overall.

Curling, on the other hand, only allows a single substitution, of a single player in game (and, technically, it is *supposed* to be for injury/illness...although that is just about the least enforced rule in history). As such, the depth of the team's "bench" is fairly irrelevant. Most teams will play with the same four players for the entire game, every game.

Curling is more akin to Beach Volleyball, Doubles badminton, or other "small team" sports than the "large team" sports.

And guess what those small team sports have in common? If you guessed "The Olympic teams are chosen from Open Competition amongst teams made eligible via clear and obtainable qualification procedures", you are correct.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-03-17 03:37PM
AlanMacNeill is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AlanMacNeill Click here to Send AlanMacNeill a Private Message Find more posts by AlanMacNeill Add AlanMacNeill to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
SkipsWhoSayNi
Harvey Hacksmasher

Registered: May 2015
Location:
Posts: 30

Thanks for the laugh, Alan 🤡

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-03-17 04:01PM
SkipsWhoSayNi is offline Click Here to See the Profile for SkipsWhoSayNi Find more posts by SkipsWhoSayNi Add SkipsWhoSayNi to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
rbi
Hitting Paint

Registered: May 2014
Location:
Posts: 133

anybody know how bobsled chooses their teams?

do they have open competition for the Olympics?

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-05-17 01:03PM
rbi is offline Click Here to See the Profile for rbi Click here to Send rbi a Private Message Find more posts by rbi Add rbi to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
curlky
Drawmaster

Registered: Oct 2013
Location:
Posts: 503

AlanMacNiel likes to give just enough pieces of truth to make it seems like his word is the gospel of truth. As always, this is not the case.

Lots of sports besides curling use the appointed method. Just to name a few gymnastics (a hybrid approach where 2 people might be able to qualify by points but rest of team is selected), equestrian teams, bobsled, luge, alpine skiing (a hybrid approach), biathalon, cross country (hybrid), freestyle skiing, nordic combined, short track skating, ski jumping, snowboarding (hybrid). I could go on, but will stop here.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-05-17 02:30PM
curlky is offline Click Here to See the Profile for curlky Click here to Send curlky a Private Message Find more posts by curlky Add curlky to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
SkipsWhoSayNi
Harvey Hacksmasher

Registered: May 2015
Location:
Posts: 30

But Bobsled would be a perfect model for Curling because there are small teams and limited substitutions. Most bobsleders ride the whole way down, just like curlers usually play the whole game.

Last edited by SkipsWhoSayNi on 08-05-17 at 02:47PM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-05-17 02:44PM
SkipsWhoSayNi is offline Click Here to See the Profile for SkipsWhoSayNi Find more posts by SkipsWhoSayNi Add SkipsWhoSayNi to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
rbi
Hitting Paint

Registered: May 2014
Location:
Posts: 133

that's why I mentioned bobsled, especially 4-person teams.

some of the other sports that curlky mentioned don't seem to apply nearly as well.

and bobsled is not a perfect match either. I imagine bobsled has fewer participants nationwide compared with curling, fewer facilities, and is specific to younger athletes. I doubt there is a Team Birr anolog in bobsled.

but still, I'd like to learn about how bobsled picks their teams if somebody knows.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-05-17 03:29PM
rbi is offline Click Here to See the Profile for rbi Click here to Send rbi a Private Message Find more posts by rbi Add rbi to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Gerry
CZ Founder

Registered: Sep 2002
Location: London, Ontario
Posts: 3887

Bobsled Qualification:
http://www.nbcolympics.com/news/bob...8-olympic-games

__________________
CurlingZone
Everything...Curling!

Please click on our sponsors' banners periodically, as visiting their sites helps keep CurlingZone.com Free!

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-05-17 04:43PM
Gerry is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Gerry Click here to Send Gerry a Private Message Visit Gerry's homepage! Find more posts by Gerry Add Gerry to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
IMWright
Hitting Paint

Registered: Dec 2014
Location:
Posts: 186

quote:
Originally posted by curlky
AlanMacNiel likes to give just enough pieces of truth to make it seems like his word is the gospel of truth. As always, this is not the case.

Lots of sports besides curling use the appointed method. Just to name a few gymnastics (a hybrid approach where 2 people might be able to qualify by points but rest of team is selected), equestrian teams, bobsled, luge, alpine skiing (a hybrid approach), biathalon, cross country (hybrid), freestyle skiing, nordic combined, short track skating, ski jumping, snowboarding (hybrid). I could go on, but will stop here.



The sports you mention that are in the "appointed" method, the scoring in the sport in general is subjective in that judges rate how they did. You don't have two figure skaters out on the ice fighting to the death (that would make for entertaining television) or until someone loses. A figure skater skates, and a set of judges rate it. So, given that is how scoring is done, yes, there will have to be a selection committee. We don't go out and say, "well, Team X played better basketball and although the score says they lost, we'll let them win anyways".

Additionally, for bobsled:

"Qualification for the U.S. Olympic team is based on international points earned during the 2017-18 season. The team will be named on Jan. 15."

I could go on, (such as where you are just completely wrong about short track skating being arbitrarily selected - see the 2014 selection criteria - https://webpoint.usspeedskating.org...nt_OtherDoc.pdf - I don't see "at the whims of a committee" anywhere; I would argue that it's actually fairly highly detailed and based on objective quantifiable data/results), but will stop here...

Last edited by IMWright on 08-06-17 at 07:00AM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-06-17 06:32AM
IMWright is offline Click Here to See the Profile for IMWright Click here to Send IMWright a Private Message Find more posts by IMWright Add IMWright to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AlanMacNeill
Drawmaster

Registered: Sep 2011
Location:
Posts: 919

Yep.

As usual, CurlKY is off the mark and disagreeing with me because I'm me.

Gymnastics *has* to be selected, and somewhat arbitrarily, as the Gymnastics team for *all* events is limited to 4 gymnasts (they vary the numbers from time to time, it used to be 5)...for both the team, individual all-around, and apparatus events.

So you can't take the 4 (for women, 6 for men) apparatus champions....you would be in danger of a team that could not compete in the all around or team championships.

Plus, let's be honest, given the current scandals....we shouldn't be looking to Gymnastics as our model of how to run a program...

Equestrian is difficult because of the horse-rider combination issue, riders ride on multiple horses in low level competitions, but only one horse is allowed per ride in the Olympics.

Bobsled bases team selection on accumulated points over the season, so you're totally wrong there, CurlKY.

USA's biathletes are only appointed if the slots allocated to the US are not filled by automatic qualifiers (http://www.nbcolympics.com/news/bia...ic-winter-games). So, again CurlKY, you're wrong.

Snowboarding team spots (http://ussnowboarding.com/sites/def...I%20AMENDED.pdf) are filled via point accumulation over the world cup season (via a filtering criteria).

In *none* of these cases are all but one team who has been competing on the World Stage made ineligible to even compete for selection to the Olympics unless they are chosen by the committee.

Curling, on the other hand, does.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-06-17 11:25AM
AlanMacNeill is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AlanMacNeill Click here to Send AlanMacNeill a Private Message Find more posts by AlanMacNeill Add AlanMacNeill to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Alice
Swing Artist

Registered: Feb 2012
Location:
Posts: 295

For Team Birr's administrative appeal Round 2, "The Hearing", who selects the hearing's judges? A standing ethics committee? Some of the same board members who allowed HPP to have and then use so much discretion?

I'm betting the hearing bench will not be anything remotely like a neutral from another sheet deciding a close call for scoring rocks. Status quo, vested interests will circle their wagons... and win this battle but lose the war ignomniously.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-07-17 04:26AM
Alice is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Alice Click here to Send Alice a Private Message Find more posts by Alice Add Alice to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AlanMacNeill
Drawmaster

Registered: Sep 2011
Location:
Posts: 919

Per the USCA Bylaws:

Section 15.6. - Hearing Panel
Upon the filing of a complaint pursuant to Section 15.2, the chair of the Judicial Committee, after consultation with the other Judicial Committee members, will appoint a Hearing Panel consisting of three (3) individuals to hear the complaint. The chair of the Judicial Committee will also appoint a chair of the Hearing Panel. Judicial Committee members may be appointed to serve on the Hearing Panel. Other disinterested individuals identified by the Judicial Committee may also be appointed to serve on the Hearing Panel. At least one (1) member of the Hearing Panel will be an athlete representative. Members of the Hearing Panel need not be members of USCA or involved in the sport of curling. It is recommended that at least one (1) member of the Hearing Panel have a legal background.

(end quote)

Note that in the event that the Hearing Panel denies the appeal, per Section 15.11, it can be appealed further to the USOC:

Section 15.11. - USOC
Any party may appeal a decision of the Hearing Panel on a complaint identified pursuant to Section 15.1.a.ii to the USOC pursuant to the by-laws of the USOC. Said appeal shall be de novo in nature.

(end quote)

I had to look this up, "de novo" means "as new", ie from scratch with no precedence attached to the initial rejection of the appeal. Assuming the USOC operates under parallel rules to the Courts, the transcript of the USCA hearing would be available to the USOC, but no special weight would be given to the decision.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-08-17 02:14PM
AlanMacNeill is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AlanMacNeill Click here to Send AlanMacNeill a Private Message Find more posts by AlanMacNeill Add AlanMacNeill to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AK267
Super Rockchucker

Registered: Oct 2002
Location: Omaha, Nebraska, USA
Posts: 1642

If it's appealed to the USOC where will it take place?

__________________
Visit The AKCA Website!!!
http://www.curlaksarben.com

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-08-17 07:38PM
AK267 is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AK267 Click here to Send AK267 a Private Message Visit AK267's homepage! Find more posts by AK267 Add AK267 to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AlanMacNeill
Drawmaster

Registered: Sep 2011
Location:
Posts: 919

I don't see anything that says clearly, but I would guess Colorado Springs by default, unless all parties allowed it to be somewhere else?

That is *COMPLETELY* a guess however.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-08-17 07:40PM
AlanMacNeill is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AlanMacNeill Click here to Send AlanMacNeill a Private Message Find more posts by AlanMacNeill Add AlanMacNeill to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
VAcurler
Hitting Paint

Registered: Jan 2012
Location:
Posts: 136

If we have a hearing in the Springs, can I make popcorn and attend in person?

Jason

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-10-17 02:12PM
VAcurler is offline Click Here to See the Profile for VAcurler Click here to Send VAcurler a Private Message Find more posts by VAcurler Add VAcurler to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Alice
Swing Artist

Registered: Feb 2012
Location:
Posts: 295

Is this online list of the USCA judicial committee accurate?

http://www.teamusa.org/USA-Curling/...ittees/Judicial

Are any or all of them conflicted out from selecting the hearing panel?

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-10-17 05:25PM
Alice is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Alice Click here to Send Alice a Private Message Find more posts by Alice Add Alice to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jamcan
Super Rockchucker

Registered: Sep 2002
Location: vernon bc
Posts: 2146

OMG, what a joke your selection process has become. Talk about a biased beauty pagent.

Todd Birr has great results and winning records against some of your 'chosen few' and he's not invited? Talk about protecting your coaching job!

Curling needs to seriously address the role of coaching and restrict its influence in deciding national representatives. If you're the best team in the field and win then you've earned the right to go.

And if you lose, stop whining about how you play lots on the tour and should get a free pass over the team that beat you.

Seriously getting sick of all these curling Prima Donnas that have popped up in the last ten years.

__________________
When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro.
Hunter S. Thompson

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-11-17 05:20AM
jamcan is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jamcan Click here to Send jamcan a Private Message Find more posts by jamcan Add jamcan to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
jimivey
Harvey Hacksmasher

Registered: Oct 2007
Location: St. Paul, MN
Posts: 11

Just another quick update on the subject... I happened to notice a new blog entry on the main CurlingZone page and it turned out to be an article about the controversy around our Olympic Trials selection process.

http://nostonesleftunturned.blogspo...-needed-in.html

I think it's a well-written article that does a good job summarizing the issue, and makes some good points about other discretionary picks and adds some history about other challenges to NGB selection decisions.

It does come with a disclaimer at the end: "This article was prepared by the author in her personal capacity. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own and do not reflect the views of any organizations that the author is affiliated with."

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-14-17 11:52AM
jimivey is offline Click Here to See the Profile for jimivey Click here to Send jimivey a Private Message Find more posts by jimivey Add jimivey to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
AlanMacNeill
Drawmaster

Registered: Sep 2011
Location:
Posts: 919

Interesting that (so far as I can tell), that blog is anonymous, and the only entry in it is this one, and that it felt the need to include that disclaimer.

fascinating....

Also factually correct (including the legal citations).

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-14-17 12:48PM
AlanMacNeill is offline Click Here to See the Profile for AlanMacNeill Click here to Send AlanMacNeill a Private Message Find more posts by AlanMacNeill Add AlanMacNeill to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dontburntherock
Knee-Slider

Registered: Mar 2017
Location:
Posts: 2

quote:
Originally posted by jimivey
Just another quick update on the subject... I happened to notice a new blog entry on the main CurlingZone page and it turned out to be an article about the controversy around our Olympic Trials selection process.

http://nostonesleftunturned.blogspo...-needed-in.html

I think it's a well-written article that does a good job summarizing the issue, and makes some good points about other discretionary picks and adds some history about other challenges to NGB selection decisions.

It does come with a disclaimer at the end: "This article was prepared by the author in her personal capacity. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own and do not reflect the views of any organizations that the author is affiliated with."




quote:
Originally posted by AlanMacNeill
Interesting that (so far as I can tell), that blog is anonymous, and the only entry in it is this one, and that it felt the need to include that disclaimer.

fascinating....

Also factually correct (including the legal citations).





Hi, I am the author of the blog. I'm glad you guys enjoyed it, and thank you for pointing this out. The blog was never intended to be anonymous; when I look at the blog from behind the scenes, it shows an "About Me" section that I didn't realize wasn't showing up until this post. I've added my name (Bobbie Todd) in the header until I get the "About Me" widget sorted out.

The reason I have the disclaimer is because I have other publications and did not want people to associate those publications with the content that is currently on the blog and will be posted to it in the future.

Also, thanks for the compliment about the legal citations. I thought I was going to have to bust out my Bluebook at one point, haha.

Last edited by dontburntherock on 08-14-17 at 05:22PM

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-14-17 05:20PM
dontburntherock is offline Click Here to See the Profile for dontburntherock Click here to Send dontburntherock a Private Message Find more posts by dontburntherock Add dontburntherock to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
biterbar
Drawmaster

Registered: Mar 2009
Location:
Posts: 555

An excellent blog with many excellent points.

Of course the answer is our "Powers that Be" watched Birr take the silver and are scared Sh**less that they could take the title and pull another Shuster, ala 2014, on them thus proving them a failure.

The only "best interests" involved in this that of the HPP.

Let them play. Every curler I have talked to this summer says the same thing, this is a joke.

__________________
"He has all the virtues I dislike and none of the vices I admire"-Winston Churchill

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 08-15-17 11:20AM
biterbar is offline Click Here to See the Profile for biterbar Click here to Send biterbar a Private Message Find more posts by biterbar Add biterbar to your buddy list Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is . Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Pages (3): « 1 2 [3]   Last Thread   Next Thread
Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread

Forum Jump:
Rate This Thread:

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
 
Eastern Time (ET)
Full Scoreboard  |  Play Fantasy Pick'em!  

MOST RECENT CZ FORUM POSTS

U.S.A. Curling
2018 Mens Worlds Tix
U.S.A. Curling
USA Olympic Trials teams selected ( 1 2 3 )
The Pit
2017 Kentucky Derby
Players/Teams Classifieds
Competitive Women's team looking for 4th player for 2017/2018 season
Rock Talk
Calgary Curling Club Summer Ice Availability
Junior Curling
Ideas for Little Rocker Program
Alberta Curling
Looking for competitive womens team to join
Players/Teams Classifieds
WJCC experienced player looking for competitive Men's team or mixed doubles partner
Junior Curling
Need Junior Female Team - Ontario
Rock Talk
Everest Curling Challenge
Rock Talk
Hokkaido Bank Curling Classic
Rock Talk
Kerry Burtnyk and Kaitlyn Lawes summer games opening
Rock Talk
New Curling emoji
Rock Talk
About your old VHS Curling tapes...
Players/Teams Classifieds
looking for a team U 18 ladies S ONT
Players/Teams Classifieds
Looking to fill 2017/18 U21 Womens team
U.S.A. Curling
USA Curling Trials (lodging, tickets, rental cars)
Playdowns
Men's ROTR Qualifying for Ottawa ( 1 2 3 4 )
U.S.A. Curling
Pittsburgh Curling Club Land Purchase & Dedicated Facility
Rock Talk
2018 Brier/Scotties Format Finalized
World Curling Tour
2017-18 full season schedule?
Manitoba Curling
West K Closing
U.S.A. Curling
Curling Night In America (Omaha)
Rock Talk
Curling Canada AGM
Rock Talk
Streaming Awards - Vote TESN
Rock Talk
Canadian Curling Clubs Rocked by Big Cable
Rock Talk
Southern Ontario Summer Curling - K-W Granite
World Curling Tour
Mixed Doubles Cash Spiel at KW Granite Club
Rock Talk
Wct-oom
Rock Talk
#SweatToCurl -Challenge
Playdowns
Women's ROTR Qualifiying for Ottawa ( 1 2 3 4 )
Players/Teams Classifieds
Looking For a Team
Rock Talk
Ostlund
Manitoba Curling
Manitoba shuffle 2017/2018 ( 1 2 )
Manitoba Curling
Thistle mens leagues - earlier start times for '17-18
U.S.A. Curling
Bucks County Improvements
BC Curling
'New' Playdown Format?
Players/Teams Classifieds
2017/2018 season
Players/Teams Classifieds
Senior Ladies or Mixed Team Hamilton area.
U.S.A. Curling
2017-18 High Performance Program
World Curling Tour
Jennifer Jones Loves to Curl - heading to Siberia ( 1 2 )
U.S.A. Curling
Summer Ramblings
Manitoba Curling
Rare Openings in Fort Rouge Evening Leagues
Fantasy Curling
Fantasy Pick'em
Players/Teams Classifieds
Looking for a men's competitive team in Ottawa
Women's Curling Tour
2017 Arctic Cup
Playdowns
Winter Olympics PyeongChang2018
Manitoba Curling
Curl Fort Rouge 2017 / 2018
Players/Teams Classifieds
Competitive Women's team/Minnesota
Rock Talk
Lethbridge Curling Club Manager
Post New Message  |  View All Forums

FANTASY PICK'EM

Player Photo
Robertson, Darcy
  Player Photo
Jentsch, Daniela
VIEW MATCHUP
September 1 -- 9:00 am EDT
Click to Pick the Winner!
Who do you think will win?

Follow CurlingZone on these networks:

Join CZ on Facebook! Follow CZ on Twitter!

CurlingZone.com: Questions, comments, beefs?